What's Wrong with These Pictures? A Contest

note: I published this article today on daily5REMODEL, and remodelers and home performance pros are weighing in with some excellent responses. Feel free to post your response here, but please also post it on d5R if you want to be eligible for the prize, a signed and inscribed copy of the forthcoming book Green Building: Principles and Practices in Residential Construction, by Carl Seville and Abe Kruger. - Leah Thayer


What's Wrong with These Pictures? A Contest


Homes submitted for green certifications are, in theory, built to a higher standard than most. Or that's the intention.

"In most cases, the contractors want to do the right thing," according to Carl Seville, who took the photos below. "But between not fully understanding what needs to be done and not having adequate time to supervise and inspect the work, things go wrong."

Seville (in pink shirt, with Michael Anschel), a former remodeling contractor, longtime green building trainer, popular blogger and author, took all of these photos. Most, but not all, were in homes he had been asked to inspect for certification under LEED, EarthCraft and/or the NAHB Green Building Standard.

And he has a challenge for you.

Each photo demonstrates at least one sloppy and/or dangerous and/or excessive building practice. Describe these problems, using the comment area below, and you could win a signed and personally inscribed copy of the forthcoming book by Carl and Abe Kruger, Green Building: Principles and Practices in Residential Construction.

The publisher's price for the book is $99.95. It's a gift from Carl and d5R to you if you provide the best response. Carl will pick the winner. [note: comments must be postedon d5R to be eligible.]

image 1

image 2


image 3


image 4


image 5


image 6


image 7


Provide your answers below if you like, as well as on d5R to be eligible for the book. Identify which photos you're referring to, and remember to include your name if you wish to be identified.

Tip: Check out Carl's blog at Green Building Advisor -- and this post in particular for some of his building pet peeves.



Views: 277

Tags: Carl, Seville, building, contest, daily5Remodel, mistakes, remodeling, science


You need to be a member of Home Energy Pros to add comments!

Join Home Energy Pros

Comment by William H Nickerson on November 21, 2011 at 5:19am

As soon as its published...WHAT!

Comment by William H Nickerson on November 21, 2011 at 5:16am

1]single top plate.

2]slopply foam job,shallow thickness

3]hole in the ductwork?

4]siding cut too low,terrible weave,water problems

5]bad valley work

6]reverse fall on attached roof

7]no flashing

Comment by Carl Seville on November 17, 2011 at 1:46pm

Jon - Thanks for the comment.  The problem with the foam is not that it's uneven, rather it's way too thin, only about 4"maximum.  The strapping was done by the framer to even out a sloped ceiling with a duct chase (no thought given to duct location).  SInce this house is in the south, thermal bridging is not much on people's minds, and in fact, it doesn't give us anywhere near the heat loss you get in extreme cold climates.  

Comment by Jon Haehnel on November 17, 2011 at 1:36pm

I think image 2 is more than uneven insualtion.  It's open cell foam insulation and that always looks uneven.  I think it is that they added strapping to the rafters to increase cavity depth and the ran the strapping parallel to the rafters when they had the chance to run it perpendicular and reduce thermal bridging through the rafters.  I'll bet the foamer asked for that because it it faster to foam with the roof bays open than with strapping interrupting the bays every 16". 

Image 5 is a classic- terrible water shed.   

Comment by Robert H on November 17, 2011 at 11:39am

1 Definately not  a job using advanced framing

2 Uneven insualtion with at least 1 area having minimal insualtion.

3  Hole in trunk line.  What are they trying to do with the insulation

4 Water is funneled in to side of house due to valley

5 Another bad valley channeling water against the structure

6 Roof slopes back to structure

7 No flashing

Comment by Bryce Cramer on November 17, 2011 at 10:02am

Photo 1 has way more jack studs than required.

Photo 2 is under-insulated in the one rafter cavity.

Photo 3 someone left an unsealed hole in supply duct.

Photo 4, valley is running into side of house.

Photo 5, wood facia is running into roofing and gutter splash....most likely will rot out.

Photo 6. Overhang to left of support post is not cantilevered.....ladder construction used, will sag.

Photo 7, no sealing tape or flashing around brick mold.




Home Energy Pros

Home Energy Pros was founded by the developers of Home Energy Saver Pro (sponsored by the U.S. Department of Energy,) and brought to you in partnership with Home Energy magazine.

Latest Activity

Kurt Shafer replied to Tom Conlon's discussion Whole House Fans - Love 'Em or Not?
"Graham, what "large fan" are you referring to?  I am fascinated by your comment…"
5 hours ago
Profile IconTom Mallard, Eugene Swier and 2 other members joined Hal Skinner's group

Radiant Control Coatings

A group where people who work with radiant barrier coatings can let others know all of their uses.See More
6 hours ago
Graham Irwin replied to Tom Conlon's discussion Whole House Fans - Love 'Em or Not?
"I think it is important to check the energy consumption of such a large fan, even assuming it can…"
7 hours ago
Hal Skinner added a discussion to the group Radiant Control Coatings

Rooftop A/C units and exposed ductwork

Lets start a discussion about rooftop A/C units and exposed ductwork. The worst place to put a…See More
8 hours ago
Richard Beyer posted discussions
8 hours ago
Brandon Walton replied to Brandon Walton's discussion EFAZ and APS Hosting Huge Welcome Party!!
8 hours ago
Brandon Walton shared their discussion on Facebook
8 hours ago
Brandon Walton posted a discussion

EFAZ and APS Hosting Huge Welcome Party!!

If your in Arizona on August 20th, stop on by and check it out!APS Home Performance Program Q&A…See More
8 hours ago
Brandon Walton posted an event

Efficiency First AZ is Hosting Huge Meeting August 20th! at Rennick's Restaurant in the Hilton Phoenix Airport Hotel

August 20, 2014 from 5:30pm to 7pm
APS Home Performance Program Q&A w/new leader Maggie Gibbs!Join Efficiency First Arizona (EFAZ)…See More
8 hours ago
Dennis Heidner replied to Jamie Kaye's discussion Flickering LED lights
""CFLs produce light by using electricity to instigate a chemical recation between mercury…"
9 hours ago
Richard Beyer joined Michael Stuart's group


This group is dedicated to knowledge sharing and discussion of infrared thermography for building…See More
10 hours ago
Profile IconTomás León, Tauran Ivall, Alex Burnham and 1 more joined Home Energy Pros
10 hours ago

© 2014   Created by Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory.

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service