Philips L Prize LED bulb not worth it

The following blog appeared on Mapawatt for the Philips L prize LED bulb cost.   What are your thoughts on the price of this bulb?  Would you recommend it to your customers when there are lower cost LEDs available?

-----------------

In March 2012 I read an article on Triple Pundit regarding Philips defending the L Prize winning LED bulb from an article written in the Washington Postcriticizing the government for handing out 10 million dollars to a company for producing a $50 light bulb.

I was all set to write a post demonizing the "right wing" Washington Post for misquoting the price of the $50 bulb when I read this line in the Triple Pundit article:

Philips states that the actual retail price of its prizewinning bulb will be closer to $20, comfortably within the L Prize requirement of $22. That’s because the bulb will be sold through partnerships with utility companies, which will offer up to $30 in rebates.


But then I saw this article on the newswire: "The award winning Philips L Prize LED bulb is now available at Bulb...". So I was interested to see what it was selling for. And guess how surprised I was when I noticed that both Triple Pundit and the Washington Post were wrong. The 10 watt LED bulb isn't selling for $50 dollars, it is currently selling for $59.99 at Bulbs.com! For.....one..... bulb.

And when I look back at the Triple Pundit note regarding the sale price of the bulb, I notice the last sentence a little more clearly. The part about the utility rebates. Which you aren't getting if you buy it online. And could utilities be wasting their money in the first place if there is a better option for consumers?

All this is surprising to me, because you can buy an almost identical LED bulb from Philips for $24.97 from Home Depot! And I did just that earlier this week.

It seems to me that Philips is only selling the L prize bulb on the merits that it hit arbitrary targets set forth by the department of energy, when in fact a much cheaper bulb (that they also produce) makes MUCH more sense for consumers. The two bulbs are compared in the below:

While the L prize LED bulb does consume 20% less watts and it does put out 17% more light, can someone PLEASE explain why it costs 140% morethan their own LED bulb?

Mapawatt is devoted to helping consumers find products, services, and strategies to help them save money and conserve energy in their homes. I'm not sure that the L prize bulb fits that criteria at this moment. In a later post, I will go into detail on when LED bulbs can make sense (especially when compared against incandescent). But at almost $60 per bulb the savings just aren't there right now (compared to 60 W incandescent based on 3 hrs/day over 10 year timeframe; this is not the case for the $24.95 LED bulb which would save you $30 over 10 years vs. an incandescent over that same time frame). I'm surehoping the price will come down, but until then...

The moral of the story: Buy LED bulbs! They use less energy, last longer, don't contain mercury, provide great light, and the right ones are great investments. Just shop around and beware of the hype machine.

Views: 1503

Tags: l, led, philips, prize

Comment

You need to be a member of Home Energy Pros to add comments!

Join Home Energy Pros

Comment by Bud Poll on April 6, 2012 at 5:40am

Hi Chris,

Unfortunately you are correct and yes we should be concerned about our governments ability to do ANYTHING right.  The only good part I see in this is that we (this country) need to be the producer of this new technology and $10,000,000 is pennies compared to the market potential of every new light sold in the USA being made here as well. Did this project get us any closer, R&D is always good? I would like to think so, but did it give us "the bulb" everyone should get started with, sorry it didn't make the list.  Fortunately, the CFLs don't last as long as advertised so we will all get a chance to upgrade to LEDs in the not too distant future.  Unfortunately, the payback analysis you gave isn't valid, as we shouldn't be comparing LEDs to incandescents, there shouldn't be many left, but rather the in-between bulb, the CFL and that makes the switch even harder.

For disclosure, I now have five 40W LEDs rotating around my house (currently 50 minus 5 CFLs) to see how they fit in.  $9.95 on sale at a local box store and unfortunately, assembled south of the border.  Where 429 lumens isn't quite enough I will look for that other bulb that Phillips is selling.  I just hope it's assembled somewhere that makes me proud.

As an additional note, I'm putting numbers on my 5 new LED bulbs and organizing the sales receipts with bar code clippings to be put in storage.  You see, at an average of 3 hours per day, 365 day per year, these things should last 50 years.  Guess I will have to put them in my will, because I don't think my warranty is going to last that long.

Bud

Home Energy Pros

Home Energy Pros was founded by the developers of Home Energy Saver Pro (sponsored by the U.S. Department of Energy,) and brought to you in partnership with Home Energy magazine.

Latest Activity

Rick Karg replied to Carly@AirCycler's discussion The (Small) Cost of Ventilation Without Recovery
"As a member of the ASHRAE 62.2 committee (and president of Residential Energy Dynamics, the author…"
53 minutes ago
Bradford E. White replied to Elizabeth Guinn's discussion ERV in need of backflow preventer.
"I would use an in-line backdraft damper such as Artis Industries or the ones made by Fantech and…"
15 hours ago
Kim Tanner posted a video

Wireless Air Leakage Testing

This webinar will discuss the use of WiFi technology to conduct and document blower door and duct leakage tests for compliance with local energy codes. The s...
16 hours ago
Profile IconPerry Grossman, Daniel Pate and Ottawa Furnace Filters joined Home Energy Pros
16 hours ago
Kirsten Richnavsky added a discussion to the group Building Performance Institute (BPI)
Thumbnail

Breaking the link between unhealthy homes and unhealthy kids

Listen in on IAQ Radio to a discussion on reducing the household triggers that cause asthmaattacks…See More
17 hours ago
Kirsten Richnavsky posted a discussion

Breaking the link between unhealthy homes and unhealthy kids

Listen in on IAQ Radio to a discussion on reducing the household triggers that cause asthmaattacks…See More
17 hours ago
Kim Tanner posted events
19 hours ago
Ottawa Furnace Filters posted a blog post

Some Useful Information about Furnace Air Filters

There is not much we can do about the air pollution outside of a house in Ottawa, Canada, but we…See More
20 hours ago

© 2015   Created by Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory.

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service