Natural Draft Orphaned Hot Water Heater

We keep running into these.

Natural Draft Orphaned Hot Water Heaters that will not pass Draft.

Any thoughts on economical solutions?

These are typically in a pre-Weatherized house.

Views: 3392


You need to be a member of Home Energy Pros to add comments!

Join Home Energy Pros

Comment by Eric Kjelshus on February 11, 2013 at 7:38pm

Add more Heat - Make the flame larger - Heat up the flue- Make the flue pipe 1/4" per ft and make as short hoz and to flue gas code  nor more than 6' Hor.   Make as high as can and add flue liner if needed.  Brick flue can take  50,000 BTU/ hr to vent  put in a flue liner and can take only  250 BTU/hr to heat up to vent.   I have seen a brick flue need the hot water heater to stay on 24/7 to vent right and not back draft.  It take a lot of heat  to keep a brick stack hot.

Comment by Ed Minch on February 11, 2013 at 11:38am


Thanks, but I understand the theory - we do over 800 retrofits a year under several states' programs and work under different intensities of requirements and QA. My question remains:

How do we know we have an actual problem?

Comment by Ed Minch on February 11, 2013 at 11:34am

Comment by Sean Lintow Sr on February 11, 2013 at 11:01am

Ed, just because an appliance backdrafts does not mean you will have any issues with CO as that is created only with the incomplete burning of the fuel. However if all the gasses vent out, an incomplete burn or CO issue is mainly mute from that perspective.

Of course my rule on this is simple - a naturally drafted appliance or one requiring indoor air (yes that includes many power venting units) has no business being in conditioned space and should be removed

Back to studies, unfortunately most deaths or sicknesses that are directly attributed to CO poisoning are missed as the symptoms mimic colds, flus, etc... Not only do we have that issue but CO detectors are only set to go off after they hit what - 70 ppm for a few hours - so many people may never even think that this could be an issue or is the problem 

Comment by Ed Minch on February 11, 2013 at 10:01am

Has anyone done any research on what happens in the real world?  Are people getting CO sickness at certain CAZ pressures?  We are not picking up any bodies and I am wondering of all of this is necessary.   It seems the only CO problems you hear about are blocked chimney's and funky installations.

Comment by Jim Peck on February 9, 2013 at 6:00am

Sean, I totally agree with you.

Our challenge is to make it Safe, Economical, and get it Funded. (Yes, Program work)

Chimney Liners have a local installed cost of $800-1200

Even then, good draft is not a guaranteed result.

Alas, we have yet to get the local utilities to approve a power vent measure.

Comment by Don Hynek on February 7, 2013 at 10:52am

Often, fixing the venting can do a world of good, at very low cost. Next step, a chimney liner will get a marginal unit to deliver a good solid draft and reliable venting. It's amazing how much better the draft is when the air volume of the flue is reduced to correct proportions.

If the draft is terrible, the chimney liner may not work, and it's costly to experiment. A power vent water heater may be the only good option.

Replacement with an electric water heater is cheap for your program; costly for the occupants. In our region (Wisconsin) electrcity is 2.5 more costly per delivered Btu than NG, about 1.5 times more costly than propane. We see very few oil water heaters.  

"Pre-Weatherized" implies "low-income weatherization program" -- in that context, a solar DHW system is neither low-cost nor user-friendly. If you get too far out in front of your skis, the low-income resident will have a really hard time maintaining a renewable system, and will never be able to fix it if it goes south on them.

Comment by Tom Mallard on February 7, 2013 at 8:01am

An aside on solar-thermal, consider that solar-thermal to pay back needs to supply more heating needs and to do that systems likely need to use thermal-fluids, these stay fluid from -30F to 550F so allow the system to store ~550F in the tank, this is about 3-times more therms than water per unit volume that normally is only heated to 150F or so.

This is enough for space-heating by adjusting capacity to needs, then collection added to supply daily capacity.

As soon as a system can supply space-heating it's chewing into bigger bills, infrared is fairly high on cloudy days so gain is there most of the time, yet the system will have a biodiesel backup to heat the fluid when gain falls too low.

Then for distribution consider that fluids to a heat-transfer unit in a room are over 10-times more efficient at moving the heat-cold around than ductwork [so-called ductless typically used with a heat-pump], and the natural system then makes total sense as the payback should be more in line with expectations for adding it.

Not aware of anyone doing this but I will on my next home I own.

My own take is to reduce the need for external energy to where the home is autonomous, collecting high heat from solar-thermal makes more sense as it can supply space-heating and that's the big bills in winter on top of hot-water & laundry.

Comment by Tom DelConte on January 31, 2013 at 7:16am

Home Power Magazine reports that a solar powered hot water heating system which costs $8,000 will not pay back for 27 years, so it's probably best to put in the cheap electric or gas hot water heater. Such is life, when an appliance must pass draft to not kill us with carbon monoxide! [CO is the really bad stuff]. An all electric home is always safest. Once you let the gas gremlin in, watch out!

Comment by j. west on January 30, 2013 at 7:50pm

I also see them frequently. Almost every time they simply are not vented properly. Check the NFPA guidelines.


Latest Activity

Alfie Davis posted a blog post
7 hours ago
Profile IconSam Compton, Cameron Home Insulation, Seth Shoneman and 2 more joined Home Energy Pros
Home Energy Magazine's blog post was featured
Eric Kjelshus replied to Gregory Cisco's discussion Abandoning under-slab HVAC ductwork which fills with groundwater seasonally.
"In Kansas City a lot of "cardboard" for supply was used in slab on grade.  1950-1970…"
Richard L. Rue replied to Sonja Persram's discussion Energy Savings Guarantee for single family dwellings in cold climate??
"Try EnergyWise Structures ( They are a NASA spin-off company that has…"
Debra Little commented on Home Energy Magazine's blog post NREL Research Finds That 22% of New Homes Completed in the U.S. in 2016 Were HERS Rated
"The avg scores are interesting. Are there comparative numbers for previous years? I thought they…"
Home Energy Magazine posted a blog post
Robert Zockoff replied to Gregory Cisco's discussion Abandoning under-slab HVAC ductwork which fills with groundwater seasonally.
"Public water systems regularly "reline" the interior of existing 50 year old water mains…"


  • Add Photos
  • View All

© 2017   Created by Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service