Gas Heaters or Electric Heaters - which one for home?

There are plenty of concerns arising when deciding which home heating solution to invest in.

The market is full of options offering so many types of space heating devices one starts to wonder which one is the best choice. Usually the types considered vary from: portable gas heaters to electric space heaters like infrared heaters, ceramic heaters or portable oil-filled radiators.

There is no rule of a thumb answer for this but what I like to do is to approach the problem from multiple angles.

 

Performance-wise gas heater beats the electric competition. Even a high-performance electric heater running on 1,500 Watts per hour like the EdenPURE or a DeLonghi oil-filled radiator is struggling to produce more than 5,000 BTUs (and an electric appliance shouldn't go higher than 1,500 Watts, it's already a great load of electrical circuit) while a portable gas heater (like the Mr Heater) offers 1,5000 BTUs. This means the gas has more potential and produces more heat but does it worth it?

 

There are a couple of risk factors when assessing gas heater safety compared to electric heaters. We must make sure the gas heater we use doesn't expose the heating element in a way it could be dangerous for children, pets or anything fire-prone. Most of the portable gas heaters fail to deliver these. The Mr Heater features a tip-over protection and a low-oxygen shutdown but do we want to test these features on our own house? I don't think so and even the idea these concerns arise - as they needed solution as the above mentioned safety features - I wouldn't recommend using them in delicate environment like a home is nor leave any turned on while unattended. In the garage or shed however, where the temperatures usually fall even lower the gas heaters power is greatly appreciated. 

 

On the safety front most ceramic heaters and infrared heaters introduce very similar risks as gas heaters do (except the carbon monoxide risk). Exposed heating elements are supposed to be kept away from furniture and children, Wouldn't suggest leave them on unattended either. While most of these electric heaters come fan-equipped can aid the heat distribution in the room it creates a constant buzzing noise which can be uncomfortable while sleeping,

- So how do we find a home heating solution which has no drawbacks?

- We didn't discuss the oil-filled radiators yet.

They are usually a bit larger than other portable electric heaters, and the reason is simple. With bigger body, the heat is radiating away on a bigger area, means more effective heating while maintaining low surface temperature. This is crucial for safe operation. Doesn't get hot enough to cause burning wounds or fire.

Now one starts wondering about the heat distribution in the room as portable radiators doesn't have a fan equipped, how is the air forced to move?

DeLonghi's solution for this challenge is to implement vertical tubes where vacuum generated is forcing the warm air out in top of the electric heater. This is why their most popular model called DeLonghi Dragon Model, because it breathes hot air. The heating output is 5,000 BTUs on 1,500 Watts, which is just as high as an electric heater will go.

Read other reviews and insights on electric heaters and portable oil-filled radiators at Review-Home.com/Space-Heaters.

 

Views: 2491

Comment

You need to be a member of Home Energy Pros to add comments!

Join Home Energy Pros

Home Energy Pros

Home Energy Pros was founded by the developers of Home Energy Saver Pro (sponsored by the U.S. Department of Energy,) and brought to you in partnership with Home Energy magazine.

Latest Activity

Chris Laumer-Giddens's blog post was featured

Mini-Split Heat Pumps are Quirky, Especially their Capacity

Mini-Split Heat Pumps are Quirky and Still EffectiveThe name "mini-splits" generally refers to heat…See More
4 minutes ago
Melissa Ulbricht's blog post was featured

When windows aren't the culprit of a leaky building, solve the mystery with an energy audit.

Liz Vogel replaced the windows and updated the heating system in her small multifamily building in…See More
4 minutes ago
Elizabeth Coe is now a member of Home Energy Pros
34 minutes ago
Trip Smith replied to Trip Smith's discussion Where to spend my marketing dollars?
"Thanks for the reply Kim! I've checked out your profile and it appears you work for the…"
40 minutes ago
Aaren Stewart posted a discussion

Let's solve this HVAC quiz!!!

Answer these three simple problems of your HVAC systems, let's see how much you know your system…See More
7 hours ago
Chris Laumer-Giddens posted a blog post

Mini-Split Heat Pumps are Quirky, Especially their Capacity

Mini-Split Heat Pumps are Quirky and Still EffectiveThe name "mini-splits" generally refers to heat…See More
16 hours ago
Jan Green posted an event

Solar Course for Appraisers at SRP's Pera Club

November 13, 2014 to November 14, 2014
"As the US continues to search for energy alternatives, properties improved with solar PV…See More
16 hours ago
Hal Skinner replied to Hal Skinner's discussion What an RCC can do with no R- insulation in the walls.
"Just like paint.  RFoller and brush or strong airless sprayer.  It has the consistency of…"
20 hours ago

© 2014   Created by Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory.

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service