Even with Polar Vortex, Hourly Pricing Participants Saved

ComEd’s Hourly Pricing program allows participants to pay the hourly, wholesale market price for electricity. By conserving electricity usage when prices are high through simple behavior changes, customers can increase their savings. Elevate Energy administers the program and provides customer services to approximately 11,000 participants to help them manage costs, including high price alerts by email, phone or text, an online bill comparison tool, a mobile app, and education to help drive behavior change and maximize program benefits.

Elevate Energy conducts ongoing research to assess savings on ComEd’s Hourly Pricing program and encourage continuous improvement. Our Research team compared fixed-price and hourly rates by calculating how many fixed-price customers would have saved money in 2014 if they had been enrolled in Hourly Pricing. After crunching the numbers, the results are in and they’re still pretty good.

In 2014, 23% of ComEd’s fixed-price customers who have a smart meter would have paid less for electricity if they had been enrolled in Hourly Pricing without shifting any of their usage. This is much lower than the findings of previous research for 2011-2013 (in 2013, 97% of ComEd customers with smart meters would have saved money, with mean annual savings of $123.52). This can be attributed to two factors that created very high market prices for electricity: extreme cold weather during the polar vortex weather event, and large increases in the capacity charge paid by Hourly Pricing customers.

In Chicago, the winter of 2014 was the coldest in over a century. January 6 and 7 broke temperature records with a low of -16ᴼF (-41ᴼF with wind chill). Electricity generators experienced unplanned outages for 22% of generation capacity. Combined with high demand, this drove hourly prices to extreme levels, peaking at $1.81 per kWh (typical hourly prices in winter are around $0.04 per kWh). Customers enrolled in Hourly Pricing responded to these extreme prices by reducing electricity use by over 10%, which allowed them to break even with average savings of $1 for the year.

Since fixed-price customers were not exposed to extreme high prices and therefore did not conserve in response to those prices, they would have experienced large mean losses of 21% during January-March had they been on Hourly Pricing. Almost none of the fixed-price customers would have saved money during the polar vortex without adjusting their usage, but in April-December the savings rate was higher and 44% would have saved on Hourly Pricing.

These extremes are not likely to occur again. PJM, the regional transmission organization that coordinates the electricity market and grid in 13 states including Illinois, has changed grid operations to prevent extreme prices in future winters, including helping generators with cold weather resiliency and creating a market to guarantee capacity during the winter as well as the summer.

In addition, 29% of customers enrolled in the Low-Income Home Energy Assistance Program (LIHEAP) would have saved money on Hourly Pricing. This indicates that even during a difficult year, hourly pricing programs are less likely to harm low-income customers.

To see a full discussion of these findings, read the Hourly Pricing Performance vs. Fixed Price Rate During 2014 fact sheet.

Looking to the future, we know extreme weather events that rendered Chicago an immobile winter not-so-wonderful-land in 2014 are likely to happen again. Programs such as Hourly Pricing save participants money while reducing stress on the grid and lowering carbon emissions. These programs work, and with the changes made after the polar vortex, we think a lot more utility customers can warm up to the idea of saving every month on their utility bill.

Want to learn more? Visit http://hourlypricing.comed.com/ or call 888-202-7787.

Views: 96

Tags: 2014, Chicago, ComEd, Hourly, Pricing, dynamic, energy, of, polar, pricing, More…rate, savings, time, use, vortex

Comment

You need to be a member of Home Energy Pros to add comments!

Join Home Energy Pros

Comment by Amber Vignieri on November 2, 2016 at 9:03am

Thanks for your interest Kobus! We have pretty amazing customers who stay in the know about the Hourly Pricing program and respond to high-price alerts to the best of their abilities. We're working hard to ensure that this winter will be full of savings, and PJM is doing their part to ensure reliability of the grid.

Comment by Kobus Niemand on November 2, 2016 at 3:01am

Amazing that the Chicago residents complied with the public request and reduced their consumption. I wonder what the cost implications would have been if they had not achieved this? I don't know if this speaks to failing, aging infrastructure, or lack of capacity. Either way, good article, interesting read & thanks for sharing it.

kind regards,

K

Comment by Amber Vignieri on October 26, 2016 at 8:55am

Thanks for your comment Bob! We couldn't be more excited about the increasing prevalence of time of use rates. We know firsthand that they save customers money and can work for a wide variety of populations, especially low-income customers. 

Comment by Bob Blanchette on October 23, 2016 at 7:36am

Looks like the days of paying a fixed amount per KWh are rapidly coming to an end. Many utilities are starting to charge Time of Use rates and Demand charges.
We have www.smarthours.com in our area.

Forum Discussions

Origin of guarded blower door testing

Started by Kim Tanner in General Forum. Last reply by Chris Clay on Monday. 7 Replies

Electro Magnetic Fields (EMF)

Started by Barry L NewDelman in General Forum. Last reply by Daniel Cullen Aug 10. 5 Replies

When is it too windy to use blower door?

Started by Brandon Walton in General Forum. Last reply by Iain Walker Aug 10. 17 Replies

Latest Activity

Home Energy Magazine posted a video

Marc Rosenbaum, Principal, Energysmiths, compulsive measurer

Home Energy Magazine's series "Legends of Home Performance". "Making a great building involves so many aspects of human experience...it's really about how th...
6 hours ago
Home Energy Magazine posted a blog post
6 hours ago
Profile IconSteve Baker, Valerie Beichner, Dave Jones and 1 more joined Home Energy Pros
10 hours ago
Home Energy Magazine's video was featured

Testing HVAC Grilles with a Blower Door

Watch home performance testing guru Corbett Lunsford test the pressure, airflow, and velocity performance of some beautiful custom carved wooden return grill...
11 hours ago

Photos

Loading…
  • Add Photos
  • View All

© 2017   Created by Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service