It difficult to imagine something bad happening as a result of doing something we feel is so good. But here's what is bound to happen, at least a few times...

  1. A manual-j load calculation is produced by an HVAC contractor or third party.
  2. The default CFM values are left in place for the final report.
  3. This report is handed off to someone that sizes the ductwork in the field.
  4. They use the CFM numbers on the Manual-J report to size the ducts.
  5. Ducts are installed.
  6. Equipment is selected to meet the total cooling load, as shown on the Manual-J report.
  7. The equipment that is to be installed is the next available size.
  8. This system blows more air that what was represented on the Manual-J report.
  9. System is installed.
  10. Balancing report is completed for ESv3. Actual CFM numbers are quite a bit larger than the targets - more than the 20% difference allowed. 
  11. Ducts are too small for the system installed. Transfer grilles are too small. System performance is low, due to low airflow.

We need to make sure that our TARGET CFM #'s on the Manual-J reports are representative of the ACTUAL amount of air the system will be moving around the house. This means that the installing contractor may need to modify the CFM targets to match the installed equipment. If you're a rater, and you're working on a Version 3 ENERGY STAR project, be sure you keep these things in mind when you're measuring transfer grille sizes or critiquing a balancing report.

Here's a post I recently did on this topic. Check it out. I would love to hear your thoughts on the topic!

Tags: duct, manual-j, sizing

Views: 367

Home Energy Pros

Home Energy Pros was founded by the developers of Home Energy Saver Pro (sponsored by the U.S. Department of Energy,) and brought to you in partnership with Home Energy magazine.

Latest Activity

Chad Mcaulife posted photos
32 minutes ago
Bob Blanchette commented on Jeremy Begley's blog post The Home Envelope : Does it Really Matter in a Heat Loss Calculation
"Infiltration makes a HUGE difference. Look at the heat loads on a windy day vs. a calm one. On a…"
33 minutes ago
Bob Blanchette commented on Everblue's blog post Poor HVAC Installation Leads to Increased Energy Use
"That explains a LOT of why HVAC system continue to be sized by the same "rule of thumb"…"
1 hour ago
Profile IconChristian Asdal and Shashank Kirloskar joined Home Energy Pros
1 hour ago
Don Fitchett shared their video on Digg
2 hours ago
Don Fitchett shared their video on StumbleUpon
2 hours ago
Don Fitchett shared their video on Twitter
2 hours ago
Mark posted events
3 hours ago

© 2014   Created by Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory.

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service