Hi everyone!  

    I am learning TREAT, so perhaps this is too simple of a question for you guys but I am kind of stuck... when TREAT asked me about the building I choose attached, considering that one wall of the building is attached to the neighbor's house, but when I check walls, all of them are set up to the outside, and so far I have not found the way to change the setting for that attached wall. Just for me to learn, is that attached wall considered towards living space? -considering that there is a firewall separating both units. 

   Your help is greatly appreciated!

                                    Luis

Views: 201

Replies to This Discussion

Hi Luis,

This is a great question that points to a fundamental tenet of energy modeling: we don't worry about surfaces (walls, floors, etc.) where there's no energy transfer.  We assume that temperatures between adjacent units (or between conditioned bedrooms) are essentially the same, so UA∂T = 0 (the delta-T is zero), and there's no point in modeling the boundaries between them.

In other words, don't model walls between adjacent units, floors over conditioned spaces, ceilings under adjacent units, etc.  You've already discovered that TREAT doesn't give you the option to specify conditioned space adjacency. 

So, unlike detached single-family homes, that will have at minimum 4 walls, a floor, and a ceiling, attached units will often have fewer.  The most "minimal" case is an inside apartment unit on a middle floor, which might have only one surface, a wall, on the Walls/Surfaces screen.

I hope this helps clarify.  Remember, energy modeling is not the same as architectural modeling -- we don't need to worry about surfaces that are there for structural or aesthetic reasons, but that have no thermal transfer.

 - Ethan

Thanks for reply Ethan,  

    Just curious, exterior walls have negative energy transfer (energy loss), heat gain from sun exposure, wind, etc, so when modeled as adjacent to the outside, with the R value of all materials, there is a calculation of that lost energy. I am thinking that the firewall should be pretty energy neutral and so I was thinking it should be represented as wall adjacent to condition space; even though I understand that walls from inside the condition space are not modeled. But the other Townhouse is not part of this condition space....  maybe I am seeing this the wrong way...  hmmm, love building science!

              Luis

Exactly right, Luis.

The other unit is conditioned also, so there's negligible energy transfer between them, so the common walls don't provide a heating or cooling load, and there's no reason to enter them in the model.

And to simplify it, there's no way to enter them in TREAT.

If you created this model with the New Building Wizard, you probably have at least one wall that you just need to delete from the model -- the one that would have been adjacent to the other unit.

 - Ethan

Great Ethan!  

I am going to give it a try!!! I know that what you say makes sense... it just feel silly modeling 3 walls

I really appreciate your comments!

                      Luis 

RSS

Videos

  • Add Videos
  • View All

Twitter

Latest Activity

Carrie Sturrock updated an event
Thumbnail

Making an Old Home More Livable: Where to Start and When to Ask for Help at Webinar

September 15, 2016 from 11am to 12pm
Making an Old Home More Livable: Where to Start and When to Ask for HelpUpgrading and weatherizing…See More
2 hours ago
Profile IconTommy Spain and Carl Johnson joined Home Energy Pros
2 hours ago
Kit Yturralde posted a blog post

Crawl Space Dehumidifiers Vs. Portable Dehumidifiers

If you start looking at the prices of crawl space dehumidifiers compared to portable dehumidifiers,…See More
7 hours ago
Profile IconBarbara Smith and Carl Johnson joined Tom White's group
Thumbnail

Weatherization

Share your concerns and successes as a weatherization professional, or information for this…See More
yesterday
Carl Johnson replied to Joel Greenberg's discussion The Truth About Windows? in the group Weatherization
"I think the appeal of replacing windows is largely on the aesthetics for most homeowners. Nobody…"
yesterday
Carl Johnson commented on Amber Vignieri's blog post Chicago Winter No Match for Retrofitted Logan Square Building
"Beautiful home! Did Josh replace the windows as well or no? Living in Chicago myself, I know about…"
yesterday
Carl Johnson commented on Diane Jackson's blog post Two Addison Projects Win Housing Innovation Awards
"These homes look great! Congrats!"
yesterday
Paul Scheckel posted a blog post

Renewable Rant: Traditional Energy!

Why, when I open up a newsletter or market evaluation report about “traditional energy” markets, do…See More
yesterday

© 2016   Created by Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service