I just published this detailed post on solar pv vs. wind turbines for installations of the same cost:

http://homeenergypros.lbl.gov/profiles/blogs/residential-solar-pv-vs

 

I'm starting to come to the conclusion that except for a few spots in the U.S. (mostly in AK, HI, or on top of mountains) residential wind will always lose to solar PV assuming optimal locations for both (i.e. no shading on solar panels, no obstructions blocking wind) and the same capital outlay at the onset.  

 

I'm going to work on another blog post highlighting this fact, because it is rarely covered by most news media who don't even know the difference between a kW and a kWh, let alone know how to do the analysis themselves.  

 

What I'm looking for is someone who can tell me I am missing something in the analysis?  Any thoughts?

Tags: comparison, solar, vs., wind

Views: 57

Replies to This Discussion

It's a reasonable start anyway. However the 35 foot tower is no where near high enough, especially with the tall trees in the photo. 90 ft would be a minimum height and mite double the average wind speed to get eight times the kwh but 110 would be better even with a cost increase. I know Southwest Wind is coming out with a low start up wind speed turbine this year and that up the yearly output of the turbine. The other factor is the life time performance and the expected life time or replacement cost at end of life.
Good input Leo, but how many residential wind turbines are on towers over 90 ft?  I wonder how practical that is in practice?  And even then, does the wind turbine outperform solar?  My gut is telling me no.

On cloudy days, especially when they are contiguous and numerous, wind will provide greater benefit.

What is the larger question?  How flexible are the people (and other entities) involved?

David, did you check out the original post? I'm speaking on an annual basis.  Cloudy days don't necessarily mean wind, and solar will still produce electricity even on cloudy days.  On an annual basis, I'd be surprised if there were many places where resi wind beats solar. 

Nope.  I responded to your question.  It wasn't serious?

Who lives on an annual basis?

Ok, I didn't word my question effectively.  What I meant to say, "Even on a 100 ft tower, does a wind turbine outperform solar on an annual basis"  Again, I'm sure there are locations where this is the case, but these are few and far between, and outside of the majority of the U.S. population.

 

Everyone lives on an annual basis when it comes to analyzing what the better return on energy investment is.

"Everyone lives on an annual basis when it comes to analyzing what the better return on energy investment is."

Then, hopefully, each is very flexible.  Lately, fewer and fewer days seem to be average days.

Well Dave, luckily I have one of the most popular posts on the web for finding your city's temperature and weather history.  Of course I haven't instructed people how they can predict the future, but based on all available information, I can tell them what their best available options are.
Thanks for what you're doing, Chris.  I hope your feeling was that I was playing with you in a friendly way.
No worries!   But seriously, let's try and get to the bottom of this issue!  I would like to do enough research and then come out with some conclusions that all Energy Pros can use to recommend clean energy systems.
At a Minnesota Energy Conference I met a wind and PV solar installer. He sells and installs both Southwest wind systems and Sunpower PV(one of the highest efficiencies in the industry) systems. He monitored both a 2.4 kW wind turbine and a 4.14 kW PV array for 16 months. Wind was at 4200 kWh and the PV at 11,000 kWh. The tower was 33ft high on flat mostly unobstructed terrain. No shading of PV however the ground mount array was automatically articulated from sunrise to sunset and the north to south angle was adjusted twice per year. This is a guess,but articulation could double the yearly output of PV. This was a south central Minnesota Location with an average wind speed of 11.5 to 14 mph depending on the exact location of the turbine.  The cost of the wind system installed was $19,500 and for the PV installed was $30,000 to $40,000. They sell a 10kw Ventura turbine that could output 17,000kwh/yr for $60,000 to $65,000.

Leo,

That's a great example.  Most people would assume that wind would kick solar's butt in MN.  Even if you halved the size of the PV array (and then had the installed cost under the wind cost) it would still produce more kWh than the wind!  

RSS

Home Energy Pros

Home Energy Pros was founded by the developers of Home Energy Saver Pro (sponsored by the U.S. Department of Energy,) and brought to you in partnership with Home Energy magazine.

Latest Activity

Christopher Talarico posted a discussion

Heating with Tankless Water Heater & Hydronic Air Handler vs. Gas Furnace

Hi,I've looked around online and haven't found a lot of good information on home heating with…See More
8 hours ago
Profile IconSara Sabol, Christopher Talarico and Aaren Stewart joined Home Energy Pros
10 hours ago
Hal Skinner replied to Andy Gostisha's discussion Disguising Ductless Heat Pump Units
"Hi Andy. The bare metal units on a roof stick out like a sore thumb .  Coating them with our…"
10 hours ago
Paul Morin replied to Stephen Standley's discussion Which reading is more reliable on a Minneapolis Duct Blaster?
"Sorry for chiming in so late.  Sean’s comment early on in the discussion was the closest…"
14 hours ago
jerry gentile posted a status
"hello- anyone challenge the written QCI exam?"
16 hours ago
Kevin Jordan posted photos
21 hours ago
Susan E. Buchan's event was featured

EEBA Excellence in Building Conference at Doubletree Union Station Hotel

September 23, 2014 at 8am to September 25, 2014 at 2pm
yesterday
Susan E. Buchan posted an event

EEBA Excellence in Building Conference at Doubletree Union Station Hotel

September 23, 2014 at 8am to September 25, 2014 at 2pm
yesterday

© 2014   Created by Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory.

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service