The days of the good ole rafter baffle are over. What are your feelings on sealing the tops of exterior wall plates? Important to do with many choices. Two part foam ( hard to get to the plate ), use cellulose bags stuffed on top of the plate ( stops all venting from soffet)

Views: 233

Replies to This Discussion

We have had good success using rigid and one part foam to get those darn exterior wall top plates. Two part foam can be cost prohibitive. We use a fireblock foam with a dispensing gun that has a 3ft barrel. The long barrel gets out to those tight spots. Once the existing insulation is pulled back (garden rake), a generous bead of foam goes down, then slide in the thickest piece of rigid foam in place. Another bead of foam over the top, push the insulation back, and you’re done. Then just repeat, repeat, repeat.
Just so I am clear - you are not advocating eliminating the soffit venting, unless you are replacing it with another type or going to a hot roof system, correct?

Hot roof's with foam - never had an issue with them spraying that area off

With soffit vents - baffles, rigid foam & 1 part foam

Using a product like smart-vent; 2 options - using CC spray foam like the rim joists then cellulose, or basically like Zach suggested
I think this is an excellent topic especially with the rush to own a spray foam rig and not understanding building science.

I like the "hot roof" type also, but I also like the suggestion of having a firred-up roof. With the decking that has the foam applied to it essentially seperated from the decking that holds the roof covering which creates the venting opportunity. I have read about these roofs and heard about them being used in cold climates which helps prevent ice damming.

Sean, would you still consider this a "hot roof"?

I think the hardest part in creating a "hot roof" in a retrofit is the level of difficulty at not only those darn top plates and those darn top plate outside corners, but also in all of the other tricky roofing design crevices that are in the market today. I have only seen a couple of jobs that have done a great job retrofitting with spray foam. And even some of those jobs have cathedral/vaulted ceilings that have been totally ignored!!! What is a building envelope when the barriers are not continuous and contiguous? A little air leakage seems to be able to cause big problems.
Jamie, first welcome aboard and secondly in response to your question - technically that would not be a "hot roof" as it is ventilated

I do agree with you on the hardest parts, but not because of air leakage, but the thermal transfer in really cold climates - if the CC foam was installed properly, the amount of air that can get through should be pretty close to zero & the only problem as mentioned is the thermal breaks (rafters, trusses, studs, plates, corners, etc... in the house) but that does apply to all houses unless the entire house is wrapped on foam outside

I should also state that the air & water barriers should be on the exterior and one should not rely on the insulation to perform that job - as now you have brought the battle inside the house. Granted insulation can help in that fight, but relying on it to do the job is an issue - as for retrofits, if there are issues with water intrusion, that needs to be dealt with before any insulation goes in the wall, no matter what type it is

RSS

Home Energy Pros

Home Energy Pros was founded by the developers of Home Energy Saver Pro (sponsored by the U.S. Department of Energy,) and brought to you in partnership with Home Energy magazine.

Latest Activity

Bud Poll replied to Bud Poll's discussion CO poisoning in Yarmouth Maine
"Hi Chad, I sure would like to hear the follow-up on what caused the CO issue down there.  As…"
37 minutes ago
Chad Mcaulife replied to Bud Poll's discussion CO poisoning in Yarmouth Maine
"I got a call yesterday from a homeowner who had a direct vent furnace installed a year ago and she…"
1 hour ago
Windzer Pierre-Louis replied to Matthew P's discussion Needed: Gas Detector and CO Detector. What do you recommend?
"Matt, I am new to the industry, less than 6 months. I love the mission of the industry; to bring…"
1 hour ago
Todd Collins replied to Nate Adams's discussion One Knob and the Pain That Inspired It
"Home performance is about comfort and energy savings.  We are working on a document about…"
1 hour ago
tedkidd commented on Shawna Henderson's blog post Sales funnels are funny shaped things
"Nice Venn Diagram. Product sales vs Consultative Solutions sales. We like the Sandler Selling…"
2 hours ago
Andrew Aliferis replied to Patrick Michaelyan's discussion Proper means to "plug" flue pipes after testing gas appliances.
"Patrick, These are what works for the programs I am involved in New Jersey and Pennsylvania. They…"
2 hours ago
Profile IconTravis Thom and Amita Singh joined Home Energy Pros
3 hours ago
Shawna Henderson's blog post was featured

Sales funnels are funny shaped things

One challenge seems to be at the forefront of a lot of the discussions I'm having with colleagues…See More
3 hours ago

© 2015   Created by Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory.

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service