Anyone ever hear of a window, or unit of insulated glass, as having different winter and summer U values? 


This wasn't on an NFRC sticker.  It was on a glass manufacturer's spec sheet. 


They listed it like this:


Winter - Air / Argon  0.35 / 0.31

Summer - Air / Argon 0.32 / 0.28


Our program requires a U value of 0.30 to receive an incentive rebate.  So obviously, homeowners and contractors want to average the summer and winter Argon fill U values to come up with an average of 0.295 and call it good.


I think it is just a piece of insulated glass that they want to have installed/retrofitted into their existing wood windows, and get an incentive for that. 


Views: 2642


Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

The winter U-value is what is shown on the NFRC labels, and should be used for code compliance and incentive programs. It is calculated at -18C (about 0F) outside, and 21 C (about 70F), and a roughly 15 mph wind speed. The summer U-value is calculated with conditions where it is warm outside and hardly any wind. This means that the U-value will be a bit better, but it is not a representative condition for heat losss. The Solar Heat Gain Coefficient (SHGC) is more important during periods with solar gain. So think U-value for heating, and SHGC for cooling.

WIndows and Daylighting Group
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory

Currently in communication with this gentleman:

Andre Anders, PhD
Leader, Plasma Applications Group
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
1 Cyclotron Road, MS 53, Berkeley, California 94720, USA
Tel. 510-486-6745, Fax 510-486-4374

He's circulating the information among his associates and will be in touch following the holiday. Will probably find it's way Christian at LBNL, who has responded since last I checked in.

BTW, Christian's advice to use the winter number is probably not what you wanted to hear regarding the available incentive. If 0.30 U is a common cut off # for incentives, I would expect manufacturers to work to that figure, although in a manufacturing environment, such changes may be a challenge. Perhaps a bit of latitude from incentive providers is in order...who is going to notice a U difference of 0.01 ?

Thanks for surfacing this mystery.
Steve, Adam,

Andre forwarded your question to me, that is why I responded here. Many manufacturers have products that meet U=0.30, since that was the cut-off for the IRS tax credit.

If you are looking for even better windows, you can take a look at this website, where you can find listing of manufacturers that meet U=0.22 and less.

Thank you for the replies! Our program does require NFRC stickers, so this guy is going to be out of luck anyways.

But I was curious about the different winter and summer U values anyways. Thanks for the response and clairificaiton!



Home Energy Pros

Home Energy Pros was founded by the developers of Home Energy Saver Pro (sponsored by the U.S. Department of Energy,) and brought to you in partnership with Home Energy magazine.  Home Energy Pros is sponsored by the Better Buildings Residential Network.

Latest Activity

Al Tibbs's photo was featured


Area of missing insulation (new construction).
5 hours ago
Elliott Management Consultants's photo was featured

Mobile Training Diagnostic Center

EMC Construction Manager, Ric Blevins, inspects a nearly completed Mobile Training Diagnostic…
5 hours ago
Diane Jackson's 2 blog posts were featured
5 hours ago
Paul Scheckel's blog post was featured

Energy Ambassadors: Cuba and Vermont

Last winter i had the pleasure of hosting a Cuban colleague for a week in Vermont. We toured the…See More
5 hours ago
Diane Chojnowski's discussion was featured
5 hours ago
David Byrnes's discussion was featured

Insulation machine preferences

I'm in the market for a new insulation machine and am unhappy with my existing plug in machine…See More
5 hours ago
Tom White posted a video

Backdrafting natural draft gas water heater

If you are concerned about Indoor Air Quality, get rid of your old school gas water heater. They often have backdrafting problems - meaning they suck air dow...
5 hours ago
Quinn Korzeniecki replied to Quinn Korzeniecki's discussion BPI Releases Revised Recertification Requirements for Home Energy Professional Certifications
"Hi Hugh, If you have over the 24 CEUs, you still must complete the field examination that is…"
11 hours ago

© 2015   Created by Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory.

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service