BPI's April Stump the Chump: What’s Wrong with this Picture?

We know, we know. There’s a lot right with this picture, such as the gorgeous view of Lake Tahoe in the background and the awesome powder for skiing. But from a whole-house-as-a-system perspective, what’s wrong with this picture? What is the owner trying to do, and what would be a better solution?

Thanks to our own Larry Zarker, BPI CEO, for sending in this dandy shot. He offers the following Winston Churchill quote to explain what’s going on here: “You can always trust the Americans to get it right, after they have exhausted every other possibility”.

Think you know what the problem is, as well as the solution? Send it to us at lmcdowell@bpi.org.

 

Tags: April, Chump, Stump, building, newsletter, performance, the

Views: 400

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

Problem is Ice Dams.  The home most likely had melting of roof snow which then refroze and created ice dams possibly causing water damage or excessive ice buildup at roof edges. This caused the homeowner to install energy intensive heat strips to melt the ice dams and jack their electric bill through the roof during snow events.  

 

This is caused by:

1)      Air leakage from penetrations near exterior wall

2)      Heat sources close to exterior wall such as heating ducts or recessed lighting cans

3)      Insulation in contact with roof sheathing causing thermal bridging to roof deck

4)      Lack of soffit ventilation

 

The solution:

 

1)      Air seal exterior top plate with spray foam. It is also important to air seal any other penetration which is delivering heat to the underside of the roof deck.

2)      If recessed lighting is installed near exterior walls, the cans should be ICAT rated to prevent air flow through the fixture. An inexpensive air tight trim kit may also be purchased to avoid changing out fixture itself. Heating duct boots can be sprayed with 2 part foam to prevent heating of roof deck.

3)      Install soffit ventilation at code recommended level at EVERY BAY that is affected.

4)      Install insulation baffles at all soffit edges in order to provide a path for ventilation and carry away any remaing heat transferred from house and cool roof deck. This also prevents insulation from contacting the roof deck (causing thermal bridging).

 

Since it is often difficult to get full insulation amounts at the soffit edge due to clearance, an optimal solution would involve installing ventilation baffles and using spray foam insulation against the baffle and as far in until a full amount of blown insulation may be used. This solution also seals any air exfiltration through the wall top plate at the same time. 

 

 

Oh, and most likely, this is the north facing roof your looking at, unless you have tons of winter shade on the southern exposure.

Congratulations to Craig Bird of Preston Insulation in Tucson, Arizona for winning last month’s “What’s wrong with this picture?”contest. Craig was not only the first person to send in the correct answer. His answer was far and away the most comprehensive, and dare we say, the most elegant in illustrating what in the world of home performance was wrong with the picture, and what should be done about it.

The picture shows a snow-bound house in front of Lake Tahoe, its roof zig zagged with heat strips.  Says Craig:

“The problem is ice dams.  The home most likely had melting of roof snow which then refroze and created ice dams possibly causing water damage or excessive ice buildup at roof edges. This caused the homeowner to install energy intensive heat strips to melt the ice dams and jack their electric bill through the roof during snow events.  

 

This is caused by:

1)     Air leakage from penetrations near exterior wall

2)     Heat sources close to exterior wall such as heating ducts or recessed lighting cans

3)     Insulation in contact with roof sheathing causing thermal bridging to roof deck

4)     Lack of soffit ventilation

 

The solution:

1)     Air seal exterior top plate with spray foam. It is also important to air seal any other penetration which is delivering heat to the underside of the roof deck.

2)     If recessed lighting is installed near exterior walls, the cans should be ICAT rated to prevent air flow through the fixture. An inexpensive air tight trim kit may also be purchased to avoid changing out fixture itself. Heating duct boots can be sprayed with 2 part foam to prevent heating of roof deck.

3)     Install soffit ventilation at code recommended level at EVERY BAY that is affected.

4)     Install insulation baffles at all soffit edges in order to provide a path for ventilation and carry away any remaining heat transferred from house and cool roof deck. This also prevents insulation from contacting the roof deck (causing thermal bridging).

 

Since it is often difficult to get full insulation amounts at the soffit edge due to clearance, an optimal solution would involve installing ventilation baffles and using spray foam insulation against the baffle and as far in until a full amount of blown insulation may be used. This solution also seals any air exfiltration through the wall top plate at the same time. 

RSS

Videos

  • Add Videos
  • View All

Twitter

Latest Activity

Steven Lefler posted a status
5 hours ago
Ryan T De La Rosa is now a member of Home Energy Pros
5 hours ago
Chris Dorsi posted a blog post

My Favorite Announcement of the Year

Each year, Habitat X engages in…See More
7 hours ago
R Higgins replied to Energy Wise Solutions's discussion No Utility Homes, Are we ready to start building Homes that are not connected to traditional utilities ?
"First off, check the laws in your area.  Drought prone areas often prohibit on site collection…"
15 hours ago
R Higgins commented on Tom White's video
Thumbnail

Building Science Insights -- To Vent or Not to Vent

"Great lecture, kept thinking, but what about existing buildings.  Too little room at eaves for…"
15 hours ago
Luis Imery added a discussion to the group Job Board
Thumbnail

Hiring: Construction Manager with High Performance Custom Home Experience

POSITION DESCRIPTIONJob Title: Construction ManagerDepartment: Construction –…See More
yesterday
Profile IconLuis Imery and Quinn Korzeniecki joined Diane Chojnowski's group
Thumbnail

Job Board

This group is for posting jobs related to all aspects of the home performance industry including…See More
yesterday
Colin Genge posted an event

Retrotec is attending the NEBB Testing and Balancing (Tab) Certified Professional Review Seminar in Chicago, IL at Hilton Chicago O’Hare Airport

June 6, 2016 at 8am to June 8, 2016 at 5pm
Building owners and tenants are concerned that the environmental performance of buildings must be…See More
yesterday

© 2016   Created by Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service