I have a 20 year old house with a 2 1/2 ton A/C for the lower floor and a 1 1/2 ton A/C for the upper floor. The 1 1/2 ton condenser went bad. The 2 1/2 ton is going bad.
I work for a commercial general contractor in Atlanta. We recently removed two functioning 5 ton Trane (5 years old) systems (cooling only) from an IT room. The room is being changed back into typical office space.
Is there a reason I can't replace my smaller units with these larger units? The IT room these units served was only 18'x20'x9' ceiling height. It felt as though you could hang meat in that IT room.
The refrigerant will need to change. I will have to add a gas heating element. Why can I not drive a race car down the road at typical driving speeds? Yes, it's more horsepower than needed but, what harm is there? Will I spend too much energy? Will the system freeze up? What?

Tags: BTU's, Too, many

Views: 152

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

If your space was designed for a 1.5 ton system, i find it hard to believe that you would consider a 5 ton. The furnace and coil to match if you found them would blow your windows out...way too much airflow. Can you say mold, mildew from short cycling and no humidity removal, energy consumption would be crazy, i could go on but this is a bad idea no matter how you look at it. The server room had a high heat load from servers and needed that size, i seriously doubt your standard residential home has that size load. 

Does the house ever feel clammy?
Do you have to keep the thermostat below 74 to be comfortable?
Is the duct noisy with the 600 cfm your current system needs?
If not, do you have ductwork that can handle 2000 cfm50 at 1/2 inch water column?

The 5 ton system you have is not 500 hp racecar engines they are 500 hp truck engines. The duct work is the transmission if you 3x the engines hp without upgrading the transmission you will have problems.

The undersized ducts will not move enough air and liquid refrigerant will likely get into the compressor and damage it.

Most air conditions have only 2 operation conditions 100% on or 100% off. Now lets imagin you want to drive your truck engine equipped Camry in stop and go traffic and your only speed control is engine 100 % or costing.  Your engine will get lots of very short run cycles.

Short run cycles are bad in 2 ways 1 it is hard on the equipment 2 AC equipment does not start removing humidity from the air until it has run for over 15 minutes.  Lots of people are comfortable 78° at 50% humidly. With short cycles you are more likely to end up at 78° at 80% and uncomfortable so the set point gets turned down and 68° at 70% is bearable most find it cold and clammy.

Also it can be bad for your health as the air in your ducts will likely be 25° below the set point. 43° ducts exposed to outdoor air will be well below the dew point water will pour off the duct and mold is possible

Do you think the 500 HP Camry gets better MPG?


Its more about run time with high RH removing, than to large over sized AC unit, in houses.    The job I am working on now is started with 9 tons and will bring it down to 5 ton need.  Now the duct size is  right with just a total of of .5 SP just as the air handler is listed.   Most jobs I do have very large loads to start with and when I finish its much smaller load.  I see very high pressers and low CFM then the coil freezes on bad duct work jobs.   I have seen 400 SF IT rooms take 20 tons of cooling   and then change hard drives to more energy lowering now 9 tons and more speed.   Most IT rooms are high CFM and low RH removal.  



Featured Forum Discussions

BPI Anaylist and installers

Started by Larry R Waters in BPI. Last reply by Quinn Korzeniecki 20 hours ago. 1 Reply

What causes a temperature plane in a home

Started by Energy Wise Solutions in HVAC. Last reply by Brad Cook yesterday. 6 Replies

Velocity Pressure Testing

Started by Horace Douglas Hunt, Jr. in General Forum. Last reply by Horace Douglas Hunt, Jr. Apr 15. 2 Replies


  • Add Videos
  • View All

Latest Activity

Chris Woods added a discussion to the group Energy Auditing Equipment for Sale, Trade or to Purchase

Minneapolis Blower Door Fan and Door frame $990 OBO

I have a used Minneapolis blower door fan (fan only, no controls or panel) and the blower door…See More
10 hours ago
Profile IconManuela L Heyn and Paul Nagel joined Home Energy Pros
13 hours ago
Bill Spohn replied to Eric Sperline's discussion Wanted: Energy Auditing Equipment for sale in the group Energy Auditing Equipment for Sale, Trade or to Purchase
"If you choose to buy new, give TruTech at call at 1-888-224-3437 option 1"
15 hours ago
Home Energy Magazine's blog post was featured

The Legends of Home Performance

A project long in the making, we're happy to finally reveal some of our Legends of Home Performance…See More
16 hours ago
Quinn Korzeniecki replied to Larry R Waters's discussion BPI Anaylist
"Hi Larry, We're glad you're reaching out to hire some BPI folks! You can also submit…"
20 hours ago
Larry R Waters posted a discussion

BPI Anaylist

Industry leader in the north bay area California. Looking for experienced professionals and future…See More
Larry R Waters joined Diane Chojnowski's group

Job Board

This group is for posting jobs related to all aspects of the home performance industry including…See More
John Nicholas replied to Jim Fowler's discussion TREAT modeling of mid-rise apartments low heating load
"So why is tenant behavior significantly different in this building?"

Home Energy Pros

Welcome to Home Energy Pros – the unique digital community by and for those who work in the home energy performance arena.

Home Energy Pros was founded by the developers of Home Energy Saver Pro (supported by the U.S. Department of Energy) and brought to you in partnership with Home Energy magazine.  Home Energy Pros is sponsored by the Better Buildings Residential Network. Please honor our Guidelines

© 2017   Created by Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service