I am looking at updating the heating and water heating systems in a rental home I recently purchased.  Currently, there is a 4 year old Burnham oil furnace with a coil for water heating.  I'm looking at adding a natural gas burner to the system, as gas lines are already in place.  With regard to water heating, I'm looking at indirect fired systems although I've received some recommendations for installing an electric tank.  Thoughts or advice?  As you can probably tell, I'm new to this!  Thanks.  

Tags: HVAC, heaters, heating, water

Views: 974

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

I have been using  Rheem or State or Brad/white PVC flued tank type hot water heater  abit more than 61% tank type  but less than 1/2 of a tankless.  can take -50 PA in the CAZ test and is cheap to flue and works well.  You have to plug it in but that not hard in a basement and still takes a 1/2" gas line un like most tankless take 3/4" or 1".    I get the PVC flued hot water heater to pass the CAZ test each time.  

What are the prices for gas and electricity?

Posted something earlier, but account was hacked. Natural gas tank heater, such as: http://www.kenmore.com/kenmore-elite-50-gal-12-year-natural-gas/p-0...

NG tank probably the way to go in most utility cost situations. Tankless may make sense - about 20% more efficient than standard tank heaters, but beware their usual shortcomings.

Could it be that you have a boiler with tankless coil? Boilers are for hydronic heating, furnaces are for forced air heating.

Is this a single family residence? Will you live in it or rent it out? Year round use?

How many bathrooms, fixtures, what flow rates, how many people in the home, etc.?

What are your goals? Best hot water comfort? Lowest operating cost? Lowest investment cost? Greenest? Any government and utility incentives in you area?

A tankless coil boiler is the cheapest investment, but has the highest operating cost as you are keeping the complete unit hot year round day and night. Plus they are typically not well insulated. Keeps you basement warm and dry. Very limited capacity. Converting it to gas only addresses one of its problems.

Hello, 

Just wanted to get your opinion on heating and cooling systems for a project in Lewiston, Maine.  The house was built in 1916, has 5 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, 1 kitchen.   
With regard to heating, there is currently a 2009 oil burning, Burnham furnace.  I'd like to add a Carlin EZ natural gas burner to the Burnham unit.  However, I've received all sorts of conflicting advice with regard to water heating.  
Here are the options, as I understand them:
  • Standard Electric Tank - 50 gallons, $750
  • Hybrid Electric with Heat Pump - $1700
  • Tankless Water Heater - $2700 to $3100
  • Standard Gas Fired Tank - $2500
  • Gas Fired Condensing Tank -  $3100 to $3500
Thoughts?  I'm trying to balance cost/budget with efficiency gains while also ensuring I have sufficient hot water for 5 tenants.  
Thanks for the help!  
Best, 
Johnny

Are including the Efficiency Maine cash rebates of up to $300 in your calculation?  Are you sure each of these units will actually supply enough hot water to meet peak demand?  Have you thought about annualized lifecycle cost = (installation cost + lifespan x Annual fuel consumption in $)/lifespan?  Considered controlling demand / consumption (i.e. comfortable ultra low shower heads 1.5 or 1.5 GPM at $20 each, lower flow faucets) already?  With 5 occupants what about falling film heat recovery (Google GFX or PowerPipe) to further reduce demand?  Are you aware of the pro & cons of each type of system?

If not, you might do well to consult a reputable Building Analyst such as Bo Jesperson at the Breathable Home to help you better understand the implications of these options and perhaps others before you pull the trigger.

Cost & comfort effective DHW is not as simple plug & play replacement anymore.

Best of luck from a coastal Maine Certified Building Analyst.

I see you're in CA but, I didn't see passive solar water heater on the list of viable options?  They can be implemented with existing tanks or even supplemented with a tank-less unit for so many residents. They're able to be configured in a multitude of ways & upfront costs.  Just thought I would add that to your daunting list of choices.  Here is some very basic info on them...http://www.mysolarpower.info/water-heaters.htm

Oops, I just saw that the rental is in Maine but, you are in CA.  An active solar heater would be an option but,  probably not the most cost effective solution.  I know of folks in Alaska that use solar energy for their hot water needs even in their dead of winter, (DIY friends) so I know it is viable even in those conditions.  Anyway, if you want to explore it at all for this, or future projects, http://www.energystar.gov/index.cfm?fuseaction=find_a_product.showP... is a good starting point too.

Good luck!

Do you pay for the fuel or does the tenant? If the tenant pays the fuel then leave the 4yr old unit alone. As a landlord you will never get enough extra in rent to justify the expense of replacing such a new system.

My suggestions is to find a gas powered heat pump. We need to avoid burning electricity for heat whenever possible. If you put the same amount of electricity in a heat pump, you can pump 4 times more heat in a climate like California.  Google for "gas powered heat pump  with water heater" and you'll an expert in not time!

Cheers,  Perry

Water heating is typically the second most energy demanding equipment in your home with heating and cooling being first. Going to electric water heater is a very costly endeavor as electric heating can be 3 - 4 times the cost of natural gas heating. It really does depend on what the kWh cost is from your utility as to how much more costly it is.

 

In California, most electricity is generated from natural gas plants, and about 30% efficiency is lost in this conversion, and another 20 - 40% is lost transferring electricity over transmission lines. Thus the higher cost for kWs of electricity versus therms of natural gas.

RSS

Home Energy Pros

Home Energy Pros was founded by the developers of Home Energy Saver Pro (sponsored by the U.S. Department of Energy,) and brought to you in partnership with Home Energy magazine.

Latest Activity

Jim Gunshinan posted blog posts
9 hours ago
H.O. Electric posted a photo

about us-team

H.O. Services is your residential Electric-Plumbing-Heating-Cooling Specialist. We are an…
9 hours ago
H.O. Electric added a discussion to the group News & Announcements
Thumbnail

Stay Cool With Easy To Install Ductless AC System!

Stay Cool With Easy To Install Ductless AC System!   Save $300.00 Off A New AC System For A Limited…See More
9 hours ago
Richard Wells commented on Diane Chojnowski's group Facebook Pages
"Three thousand home energy efficiency audits, and nearly a thousand retrofits in four short…"
11 hours ago
Richard Wells joined Diane Chojnowski's group
Thumbnail

Facebook Pages

Does your company or organization have a Facebook Page?This group is for pros who have facebook…See More
11 hours ago
David Baerg replied to Blake Shurtz's discussion Air sealing wood-burning fireplace from the crawlspace below
"Hi Blake, Do you mean around the underside of the hearth?  Are you trying to seal between the…"
12 hours ago
Tom White's video was featured

Rebirth Realty: Restoring Detroit properties for Venture for America Fellows

Its been a long, cold winter, but we've made significant progress in the restoration of 760 Virginia Park. Join Tim Dingman on a walkthrough to see what we've done.
13 hours ago
Kim Tanner added a discussion to the group Multifamily Buildings
Thumbnail

Blower Door Applications Guide

TEC and Camroden Associates have released their big building testing manual, Blower Door…See More
13 hours ago
Profile Iconmichael coleman, Dan Liska and Rob Moreno joined Home Energy Pros
14 hours ago
Christopher Morin's blog post was featured

5 Things New Energy Efficiency HVAC Contractors Need to Know

1. Do not sell on Price! Use 'Simple Payback'The price of High-efficient equipment will undoubtedly…See More
yesterday
Jim Gunshinan's blog post was featured
yesterday
Kim Tanner commented on Diane Chojnowski's group Home Energy Pros on Twitter
"Follow The Energy Conservatory on Twitter! We'll follow…"
yesterday

© 2014   Created by Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory.

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service