Real data on the magic of Low E coatings for cold climates?

I bet most of you are familiar with the claims of the window industry marketing a Low-E coating as a Cure-All for any house, any climate and any window, no matter what direction it faces. 

You have likely seen the heat lamp test that make people think that their products have some serious insulating properties. 

While I am not doubting on the effectiveness of Low E coating for cooling-dominating climates (installed on the windows that the Sun shines through) I have real doubts on how effective it is for cold climates.

There is a claim that a HUGE portion of the heat that escapes through a window does so in the form of radiant heat and Low E coating reduces it. 

I am sure Low E is very effective for reducing radiant heat loss. I am very skeptical on the size of the portion of the escaping heat being radiant.

And then I am also thinking that all the rejected solar gain in the winter must be greater than the amount of heat we trapped inside. (just because Sun's surface is about 10 000F vs 68F for the surface of the objects inside a home)

I bet many of us would benefit from reputable data on the portion of the heat that escapes through a window in the form of radiation.

Opinions, thoughts and facts appreciated.

Views: 264

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

Low E helps in summer when the sun is at a different angle.  The UV rays reflect differently then the winter, when the sun is lower.  Heat is better reflected in summer versus winter due to the angle of the sun during the seasons.  The solar gain in winter comes from the sun's angle allowing more UV/Heat in this way as well, since it is not reflected by the Low E as easily.  As far as Low E helping during cold months, the radiant heat form interior lighting gets a slight gain in heat by reflecting heat from the windows into the home.  Not in dangerous amounts, just enough to help a little in comparison to non Low E coated windows.  Interesting stuff.    There is a lot of information, sometimes too much for the consumer.  It is always best to do research from homeowner testimonials as well.  Great post by the way

-TONY

Denver Window Replacement

So much of this depends on the size and orientation of the window.  North-facing picture windows are more common than one would suspect, and with our high altitude dark nights, you can really feel the "suck" from the night sky.

New Mexico has adapted the IECC to be more "passive solar friendly."

http://www.emnrd.state.nm.us/ECMD/FORMS/SolarWorksheet.xlt makes it relatively simple for a building official sign off on a design.

RSS

Home Energy Pros

Home Energy Pros was founded by the developers of Home Energy Saver Pro (sponsored by the U.S. Department of Energy,) and brought to you in partnership with Home Energy magazine.

Latest Activity

Ben Jacobs replied to Mike Kandel's discussion Have you heard!? BPI's BSP Certificate Approved as Home Energy Score Prerequisite!
"I am very pleased to see the collaboration between the Building Performance Institute (BPI) and the…"
17 hours ago
Profile IconComly Wilson, Pete Stoermer, Billy Ray Griffin and 1 more joined Home Energy Pros
18 hours ago
Stan Kuhn replied to Mike Kandel's discussion Have you heard!? BPI's BSP Certificate Approved as Home Energy Score Prerequisite in the group Building Performance Institute (BPI)
"Mike, are there any statistics on the number of HES ratings performed, by all providers?"
21 hours ago
Mike Kandel added a discussion to the group Building Performance Institute (BPI)
Thumbnail

Have you heard!? BPI's BSP Certificate Approved as Home Energy Score Prerequisite

The Building Performance Institute's Building Science Principles (BSP) Certificate of Knowledge has…See More
21 hours ago
Mike Kandel posted a discussion

Have you heard!? BPI's BSP Certificate Approved as Home Energy Score Prerequisite!

The Building Performance Institute's Building Science Principles (BSP) Certificate of Knowledge has…See More
21 hours ago
Shawna Henderson posted a status
"New Blog Post @HomeEnergyMag Why I like Dumb, Do-Nothing Houses http://shar.es/1WSOIX"
21 hours ago
Larry Gorman posted a discussion

Hobo Data loggers for sale

I have recently retired and no longer have need of these, which are all in like new condition.  I…See More
22 hours ago
Laurel Elam posted a blog post

Over 146,000 Homes in the U.S. were HERS Rated and issued a HERS Index Score in 2014

In 2014 there were 146,860 homes in the United States that were energy rated by certified RESNET…See More
23 hours ago

© 2015   Created by Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory.

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service