Is anyone game for putting together a rebuttal to this article regarding "Green Homes being Unhealthy?"

This article came out on June 8 and deserves a response from DOE and some Home Energy Pros!

 

Green Buildings Hazardous to Health? Report Cites Risks of Weatherization

http://www.foxnews.com/politics/2011/06/08/green-buildings-hazardou...

 

This is the kind of fodder that gets people to debunk home energy efficiency improvements.  It reminds me of the articles a few years ago bashing the Energy Star program because there may have been some errors in calculating efficiency...

 

Thoughts?  What are some good points to make in a rebuttal?  I'm thinking ERVs as part of any major changes to the envelope.

 

Powell

Views: 111

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

Actually from the little they stated, they are right on most points - the only item one could pic on is the word untested, as many of these items have been tested & we know what works, what doesn't, and what can cause issues.  

The problem falls on those that don't fully understand all the issues and  slap insulation in walls with bulk water issues, tighten up the house without ventilating right, etc...

3 words - consider the source- !!

For those of you who are ripping on Fox for the article...

If you would look a little closer and do your due diligence, you would find that this an AP story, not a Fox story. Fox is only relaying the message put out by AP on a study done by someone else (Institute of Medicine).

In other words, Fox is only the messenger in this case and should be treated as such.

John,

I've looked closer and cannot find evidence that anything other than the photo accompanying Fox's article is AP.  Please provide the link to the AP story that you (seem to have) found.

Here's a link to a description of the report at the site of one of its sources.

Perhaps too eager to mock green, Fox gave the story an unfortunate slant by putting ASHRAE & BPI standards outside the frame.  I agree with Sean.

You can definitely cause more problems than you solve by implementing poorly planned changes to seal your envelope but it's just frustrating to know that some people will read a report like this and use it as an excuse not to act at all.

 

I think a response from DOE on how following established standards and guidelines can prevent any negative impacts from an energy efficiency upgrade is warranted here.  Maybe a comment on the importance of getting a certified professional to perform energy efficiency upgrades to avoid such problems.

Why single out "Green" construction?  As an Energy Star verifier, I look at many new homes, both in and out of the program.  Without verification it is common to see attic baffles installed incorrectly and insulation missing in critical spaces for example, inviting not only poor performance but Ice damming in the winter, roof damage and mold.  This is just one example.  This isn't a "green" problem.

In existing homes, it's more likely that the ductwork is defective in some way than not.  It's not breaking news to find a supply duct disconnected causing the house pressure to go negative which sucks fumes in from the garage and under the house.

Or how many homes are built with no return air relief from the bedrooms which causes the core of the home to go negative just by closing the bedroom doors?  This isn't a "Green" problem.  At least we in the green industry are aware that these are issues and know how to correct them.

Powell,

Why haven't you nominated yourself instead of suggesting that someone should do something?

DOE might not be the best messenger to a segment of the population that believes DOE should be eliminated so that the government can be smaller.

If you draft a rebuttal, some of us would probably be happy to help you polish it and many of us might sign on.

Joe Romm weighed in on this today.

 

Every homeowner should carefully research the contractor or firm as well as the measures that will be implemented in her/his home. Most of my best work has been removing and repairing crap work installed by other contractors. The only thing missing in Fox's consumer protection/public health piece is "hire a certified building performance professional."

 

Fox's sloppy journalism aside, educating the public is the job of the building science community.

RSS

Videos

  • Add Videos
  • View All

Twitter

Latest Activity

Amber Vignieri posted a blog post
6 hours ago
Evan Mills posted a blog post

Looking Back and Looking Forward: Home Energy Pros at 5 and 5000

Over the past five years, the Home Energy Pros social network has grown from a twinkle in our eyes…See More
7 hours ago
tedkidd replied to Diane Chojnowski's discussion Poll: How confident do you feel about the future of home performance?
"Thank you for sharing this trend! Full disclosure, I did NOT ask Bob to post that! If you have 2…"
7 hours ago
Bob Blanchette replied to Diane Chojnowski's discussion Poll: How confident do you feel about the future of home performance?
"I see fixed monthly grid charges continuing to increase while cost per therm/kwh/gallon remain…"
7 hours ago
Quinn Korzeniecki posted a discussion

Vent Cap Systems and SENSIT Technologies Products Added to BPI Product List

The Building Performance Institute, Inc. (BPI) has recognized four new products in its …See More
10 hours ago
Simon joined Diane Chojnowski's group
Thumbnail

Online Training

Online training coursesIf you provide ongoing online training for home performance or…See More
yesterday
Simon added a discussion to the group Energy Auditing Equipment for Sale, Trade or to Purchase
Thumbnail

Wanted - Blower and door frame kit for Minneapolis system

Hi everyone,I'm new to this line of work and have bought some equipment (Minneapolis blower door…See More
yesterday
Simon replied to Steve Mann's discussion TEC Blower Door Frame in the group Energy Auditing Equipment for Sale, Trade or to Purchase
"Hi, I'm interested, but could you send to UK?,I'd pay shipping of course. My email is :-…"
yesterday

© 2016   Created by Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service