I am working with a client on a home addition, and one element of the design is a wine cellar. Here are some basic facts about the existing home:

  • Built in 1920's
  • Located in Detroit metro area on an urban site
  • Full basement, 36" foundation wall above grade, concrete, no known moisture issues,

From my early research into the topic, the opinion amongst the wine crowd seems to be that A/C is a basic requirement for any wine cellar. I would like to challenge this assumption and see if we can build a passively cooled room.

The homeowner wants the ability to store up to 500 bottles. Due to the nature of the kitchen addition, and over-due HVAC upgrades, there are a lot of possible approaches available to us. One idea I would like to consider is the use of Earth Tubes to draw in ground-temperature air into a basement space. 

Does anybody have experience building out passively cooled wine or root cellars?

Tags: addition, cooling, earth, passive, tube, wine

Views: 1883

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

Hi Nick,

While you wait, I'll keep the thread open.  One of my concerns would be circulating air into the ground to be cooled could also create an accumulation of moisture with all of the musty related problems.  And it would not be passive, you would need a fan to move that air. 

How passive do they want to get? 

Bud

I suppose I meant passive in the sense that I don't need to add a dedicated A/C system or supply line to the room - so a fan would fit the bill. The moisture build up is a concern of mine, too. 

It is called a cave, that is about the only "passive" environment that will keep it around 55 degrees with 70% humidity - the closer you get to the surface or into a house the more conditioning you need

Root cellars vary based on climates & location - best to contact your local coop for advice from those that do it in your area

Nick, the only experience I have is with : http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ground-coupled_heat_exchanger .

A simple home with a perfect basement wall and floor, however, should never be permeated. It's just more sensible to enclose a room down there and use goold old HVAC to maintain desired temp & humid. Great luck with your project!

Thanks for the link. Part of the reason I was asking was exactly because of my concerns of punching holes in a perfectly good foundation wall. 

For a root cellar, a very clever designer covered the entire basement slab with dimple mat (Delta FL), then R-10 of XPS, then subfloor, etc.

The root cellar is a large closet in the basement that is air-sealed and insulated from the rest of the basement.  The dimple mat flows under the closet walls,  and is open to the root cellar.  There is an efficient low-CFM fan to exhaust any potential ethylene (from vegetables) to the outdoors. 

This design uses the entire basement slab area to exchange heat (or "coolth" to non-techie folks) and should be able to maintain 55 degrees in the root cellar/closet year-round.  The R-10 above the dimple mat in the rest of the basement will insulate the slab from heat delivered to the finished basement.  As an additional benefit, this also negatively pressurizes and exhausts the entire basement slab, thereby reducing the risk of radon as well as moisture intrusion.   

Good luck on your project!

Thanks for the reply! This sounds like a promising approach. The slab is about 600sf, uninsulated and >4' below grade, so I think it could work as a heat exchanger. According to this site, a 25sf area would accomodate the size of the cellar needed. I will throw these numbers at the engineer in my office for a gut check. 

Hello Nick,

Joe Lstiburek has a nice article on wine cellars.  It is also available on the buildingscience.com website.   You might have already come across this in your research: http://www.buildingscience.com/documents/insights/bsi-010-wine-cell...

I think it appropriate to regard A/C as something you would only need if you had bad design, bad implementation or insurmountable location contraints (e.g. a penthouse on Michigan Avenue (poor fella!) or a home that needs to be built on piers on the coast of South Carolina).   In Detroit, you should be able to create a cave.  Instead of digging down 20-40 feet, use insulation to thermally separate the wine cellar from exterior/interior conditions.  Thermally couple the wine cellar to the ground - the part that is 4 or more feet down.  You can also make ground "deeper" by insulating it with a rigid insulation foundation skirt.  If you are putting a new foundation under the addition, then you have great opportunities to do this right. 

Remember to insulate and provide vapor control underneath floor framing that is above the wine cellar.  In fact you should separate all wood framing from the wine cellar conditions.

The concept that Marie relayed is interesting and clever, but I think a wine cellar design should focus on radiant and conduction transfer of heat and not rely on or induce a lot of airflow.  Plus, I really don't like the idea of using a wine cellar as a fat section of radon vent pipe. 

Enjoy!  Cheers,

Ken

That's a great link, thanks for sharing it! I agree with you about not venting subslab vapors through ambient air. It looks like Lstiburek's approach is similar in the sense that the concrete slab acts as a heat sink. 

There's always glass! http://www.houzz.com/photos/wine-cellar/glass-enclosure

might not meet temp/humidity goals, however

RSS

Home Energy Pros

Home Energy Pros was founded by the developers of Home Energy Saver Pro (sponsored by the U.S. Department of Energy,) and brought to you in partnership with Home Energy magazine.

Latest Activity

Dennis Heidner replied to Patrick Michaelyan's discussion Vinyl Siding with Integral Insulation
"The observation about rot is important.   I agree. One of my complaints with some of the…"
17 hours ago
Jennifer Schenk added a discussion to the group Job Board
Thumbnail

Job Opening - Energy Programs Manager - Frisco, CO

Energy Programs Manager - High Country Conservation CenterJob DescriptionGeneral Description of…See More
20 hours ago
Jennifer Schenk joined Diane Chojnowski's group
Thumbnail

Job Board

This group is for posting jobs related to all aspects of the home performance industry including…See More
20 hours ago
Avi Yashchin posted a status
""Will Online Learning Replace the Classroom?" Read my full article on HuffPost. http://huff.to/1cNCOie"
20 hours ago
Profile IconTerrell, Jennifer Schenk, Amina Lang and 3 more joined Home Energy Pros
22 hours ago
Patrick MacRoy commented on Melissa Ulbricht's blog post How to Optimize On-Bill Financing to Help Illinois Building Owners Invest in Energy Efficiency
"Many of these recommended improvements are included the Clean Energy Jobs bill recently introduced…"
yesterday
Susan E. Buchan posted a status
"EEBA 2015 Conference Call for Papers extended! New deadline: 3/6/15 at 5 PM CT Submission details: www.eeba.org/conference/call-for-papers"
yesterday
Casey Gesell replied to Casey Gesell's discussion Looking for home improvement companies to join our dealer network!
"Hi Patrick, What is your time frame for relocating? Would you be interested in operating in the…"
yesterday

© 2015   Created by Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory.

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service