Heating with Tankless Water Heater & Hydronic Air Handler vs. Gas Furnace

Hi,

I've looked around online and haven't found a lot of good information on home heating with hydronic air handlers used in conjunction with tankless water heaters (TWH). I would be interested to hear from anyone who has experience with these "combined" or "integrated" space- and domestic water heating systems.  I'd like to know a few things, especially as they compare to a condensing gas furnace:

- How efficient are these systems?  I've read that they match the efficiency of the water heater, so if you have a 94% efficient condensing TWH, your home heating is then 94% efficient as well. Of course, this does not mean that they necessarily heat as effectively as a condensing gas furnace, since the heated air from these systems is not as warm as that from a gas furnace, correct? 

- What are your thoughts on ease of installation and ongoing maintenance requirements? I have heard of issues with scaling, and a need for very frequent cleaning of the inlet strainer to the TWH.

- When the water from the air handler is returned to the TWH it is much warmer than typical incoming water to a TWH.  It is my understanding that higher incoming water actually reduces the efficiency of a condensing TWH - is this still true with current condensing TWH models?

- Bottom line, would you put in one of these systems, or opt for a separate condensing gas furnace?  Are there situations when you would choose one over the other?

I'm interested to know more about these systems in general, but also have a specific home in mind: a 2400 sf home in Portland, OR built in 1928 (currently with little insulation), that has a condensing TWH already installed.

Thanks for any insight you can offer!

- Chris

Views: 3070

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

When it costs the same price as 2 separate systems there is no juice regardless of how hard you squeeze.

Only a nightmare for future service techs, there will never be a part on the truck to fix the system, maybe not even at the supply house. Parts for tankless water heaters are special order, and not every tech can work on them.

I've looked at tankless water heaters and I'm not seeing any juice for the squeeze there either. They simply don’t' save enough energy to justify their high upfront installed cost and more complex maintenance/parts availability.

As you have pointed out, on a tight house is it even worth paying an ever increasing monthly fee for the gas meter charge, or just go all electric? Our local electric company gives cheaper rates in the winter, cheap enough that 3/4 of all-electric homes use RESISTANCE HEAT as a primary heating method.

RSS

Home Energy Pros

Home Energy Pros was founded by the developers of Home Energy Saver Pro (sponsored by the U.S. Department of Energy,) and brought to you in partnership with Home Energy magazine.

Latest Activity

Paul Raymer's blog post was featured

What does it take to be a certified Home Energy Professional Quality Control Inspector (HEP QCI)?

A quality control program requires knowing a lot about a lot of different subjects.  A HEP (BPI…See More
3 hours ago
Bryan Pringle replied to Bryan Pringle's discussion Dense packed cellulose in basement?
"Can you tell me more about how the plastic makes the moisture worse?   I understand that in…"
6 hours ago
Profile IconMatthew Cooke, yasmine smith, myacand heat and 2 more joined Home Energy Pros
6 hours ago
Bryan Pringle replied to Bryan Pringle's discussion Dense packed cellulose in basement?
"I like cellulose because of its air leakage reduction property and the ease of making a quality…"
6 hours ago
Bryan Pringle replied to Bryan Pringle's discussion Dense packed cellulose in basement?
"This example is the reverse of my suggestion.  I would do high end vapor barrier against…"
6 hours ago
Al Heath replied to Bryan Pringle's discussion Dense packed cellulose in basement?
"Really?  Go back and read these posts again.... "play ground for mold."  I…"
6 hours ago
Mary Desilva posted blog posts
7 hours ago
Kim Tanner posted a video

Single Family Residential Air Leakage Testing

This session will cover the basics of air leakage testing on a single family home as well as issues that affect the accuracy and repeatability of the test. T...
7 hours ago

© 2015   Created by Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory.

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service