I'd like the experts here to weigh in on this.  I've been hearing a lot of claims about the better IAQ you get with geothermal systems.  In my mind, a forced air system is still a forced air system, so I'm not sure if there is any validity to that claim.  But I'm not an expert.  If you feel one way or another, please post, and substantiate your position with the facts.  Thanks!  I really look forward to everyone's response on this!

Views: 188

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

Hi Trish,

I cannot think of any reason why a ground source unit would provide any better IAQ than a conventional heat pump, with one exception. The ground source unit has no need to defrost. So there will be no reverse cycle cooling calls in the heating season. Consequently, the risk of "dirty sock syndrome" could be reduced. But the dirty sock microbe doesn't visit every household. So it seems a stretch to make much of an issue about it. 

On the other hand, if you are comparing ground source with a gas or oil fired forced air furnace, there are considerable differences. One that is seldom talked about is the compounds that can emit from heat exchangers. Some chemically sensitive individuals will have difficulty with the cutting oils and other chemicals evaporating in the air through the ductwork. It seems about 25% of the population are disposed to have such reactions (based primarily on hereidty). Of course any time you have a fire in the cave, it increases the risk of gas or oil leaks and combustion byproducts. CO will get you regardless of your DNA.

With very long run times the GS heat pump can clean the air better with  wet coil than most filters.  I took an air advice particulate counter to compare dry coils VS wet coil and wet coil was = to merv 8.    I hear that GS HP do not need yearly cleaning  I disagree.  the coil still get dirty, filter still need to get cleaned/replaced, parts still need to be replaced - motors relays get pitted, go down,  stick, drag.  I find most GS heat pumps still need 2 hr yr "tune up"  " cleaning"  I do not put gages on but will cheak amp draw, SP, temps, stat and operation.  Back to better IAQ  over all yes only with better air flow and better filter. 

RSS

Home Energy Pros

Home Energy Pros was founded by the developers of Home Energy Saver Pro (sponsored by the U.S. Department of Energy,) and brought to you in partnership with Home Energy magazine.

Latest Activity

Bud Poll replied to Chad Mcaulife's discussion BPI QCI Cert.
"I can't think of any test I've ever taken where I wasn't able to determine what I…"
4 hours ago
jerry gentile replied to Chad Mcaulife's discussion BPI QCI Cert.
"you are spot on my friend-- during the exam I said this is ridiculous--- I have bpi certs for…"
9 hours ago
Eric Kjelshus commented on Jeremy Begley's blog post The Home Envelope : Does it Really Matter in a Heat Loss Caculation
"IT all matters,  I lot of sealing,  A lot of air barrier.  A lot of "R" A…"
21 hours ago
Michael Dunseith posted a status
"BPI Infiltration and Duct leakage (IDL) Certified"
yesterday
Jeremy Begley posted a blog post
yesterday
Kim Burnett joined Sean Lintow Sr's group
Thumbnail

Best Practices (Residential)

Best Building, Retrofitting, or even Auditing Practices - what are they, what should change, what…See More
yesterday
Kent Mitchell commented on Adam Swain's blog post Top Worst Crawl Space Insulation Ideas
"Hi Adam - It sounds like you may be referring to enclosed crawlspaces - Here in the NW we've…"
yesterday
peter chang replied to Damien Greenfield's discussion Is there is cost saving for you in having a tankless water heater?
"I think it is quite possible the greatest savings will be realized by the lowest volume users. I…"
yesterday

© 2014   Created by Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory.

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service