Right now I can get a small supply of Philips L Prize 60w Led bulbs at an attractive price. Is it worth switching my home and business over if I already have CFLs installed? The CFLs always seem to burn out early, for some reason. The one I can get is the 9290002097 model no. LED Bulb Test . Any thoughts or reliable calculators? Thanks in advance for your reply! Tom D
specific model: 9290002097 listed as 423244 on UPC
The contention that current production LED luminiares run hot-
Well it's true - while at the same time I would say that depends which
luminiares you're speaking of are your talking about cheap chinese
made ones that use DC/LEDs and have poorly designed light engines Yep
those suckers do run hot -
However - to refute the point I could speak to
you about LED products that utilize AC/LEDs in their design - THEY DON"T
run hot - there is a whole subclass of luminiares that use this approach - they
come in common form factors ( A-19s, Par lamps, B-10s etc) my guess
is you made a generalization there- And then there are "newer Dc Led
products" ie Philips Fortimo the unit I have in front of me - Its been on for
several hours - the light engine module is at 88 degrees and its slim
profile heat radiating fins are reading 99 degrees - this from my I/R
CAMERA - My cheap Black& Decker IR thermometer says 100 -
either way I wouldn't characterize the heat output as very hot -
these examples are a couple of degrees more/ less than skin temperature.
just adding that to the conversation- also alternate materials for
luminiare construction can be found - ie High temp therm plastic materials,
ceramic, carbon fiber so thats another part of the rebuttal process-
- I'm trying to refute things that are presentated as facts by folks who's
acumen on the topic may be a little lacking it's part of my mission to
advocate, spread the word & get fact based info to the masses !
I'm glad to read that progress is being made on the technical aspects of LED lamps...exactly what I predicted.
Can you explain to me why I should pay $20 or more today for a product whose steepest price drops have yet to come?
When I paid $20 twenty years ago for early CFLs I admit I was wowed by the "cool" factor. Now I'm older greyer jaded, and more patient.
Is it a good bet a 60 Watt equivalent LED will like both cost much less in two years, last even longer, use even less power, and dim better? What's the hurry?
Its the old adage you get what you pay for - some aspects of
the current price points involve You the average customer paying for
2009 technology IP ( sorry it's been built in to the cost's) the average
customer does't realize there is gold in light engines design - thats a
costly component - if you want things like better optics - they cost too !
Thats the For now part- as the SSL industry evolves it's true prices
will come down - so the Undesirable $9.99 40 watt equiv- LED at HD
IS ALREADY the minimal resistance price point - and likewise
a lot of other form factor price points will be lowered - but for what
a LED lamp w/o built vacancy sensor, or one that is stuck on a single
CCT ( until color shift occurs- due to inferior design & components) ?
The good stuff will always fetch a higher price , but as the value of LED
luminiares rests upon them being the Right products - on multiple levels
The whole pricing paradigm is going to be fluid - due dilegence in the
selection product is critical - if you wait another few seasons you will
see OLED s and other options devalue LED products that work
ok , but just OK - they will be screw based lamps that fill a need.
If your needs can wait- absolutely prices for pedestrian - common stuff
will drop - most of my products cost me $7 to $35. - not obscene consider
-ing when I expect a decade of use from them, Oh and these "pedestraian
- shelve ready products are using a penny or two for daily operations
- Maybe a CFL can do ok - but, Oh the atrocious color quality - their
inappropriateness of use when coupled with controls - its a value propoposition. Some want cfls- to each their own...
Not every proposition gets an affirmative response - I get that !
As I often say" go ahead do what you will - it's a semifree country"-
but I have an environmental sensibility - I try and do whats best for
my region . Eventually in 8 years or less EVERYONE will be
using the tech of that timeframe !
The Phillips L Prize 60w equivalent Model 9290002097 has been updated to 10w, 27.4yr, 940 lumens, 2700k. It costs roughly fifty dollars. It requires a three inch extension in a standard high hat fixture, available from china for an additional three dollars.
If you already have CFLs installed throughout your home which use about 20w each, so that you can actually see, the payback period of the LED is so long it's not worth calculating. However it is known that certain brands of CFLs last longer than others, complicating the calculation.
My favorite magazine is currently evaluating my favorite LED, above. They will weigh in shortly. In the meantime, we have gov't tests of early L Prize bulbs, which we know to be flawed, since they only place the bulbs in a hot box. In the real world, bulbs are exposed to voltage surges, vibration, excess heat, and installation and removal, which shorten their lives. The LED technology is improving quickly, so that it makes it impossible for a person to know when to jump in.
As I told my spouse, as a guess, maybe $5-10 is the right price point to convert from CFL to LED. I ignored your talking down statement about the computer vs the pencil. Please continue to confuse the rest of the world, but leave me untouched. I'm at an advantage here as I'm not selling LED technology, only seeking best technology available at a low and reasonable cost! We're talking about converting from CFL to LED here, not incandescent to LED! t
I know the Philips product line well - I sell them and use them
If my passionate advocacy is working against me in using a" comparision '
then it's a part of my message delivery I'll have to work on.
There is no benefit from me "turning folks off w/ a derisive tone".
As for the choice of a CFL vs LED - the CFLs are so inferior that
it defies me why people choose them ( they had a peek popularity
of (19 %) and thats been decreasing and the industry info I have is that
by 2018 - 2020 they will be phased out - none too soon - how many
other items that contain neurotoxins do we bring in to our homes ?
AS for confusing people _ I try do the opposite.
Our house is 99% CFL - sole exceptions are refrigerator and oven interior lamps. We are perfectly happy with them.
The one type of CFL that consistently fails to satisfy is the fully enclosed spiral within a sphere typically deployed over vanity mirrors (several of our rental properties have these but not our main home). The enclosed spirals seem to take a minute or more to warm up. In those fixtures I now deploy GE Hybrid "bright from the start" bulbs that fire a halogen for the first minute.
As a solid state lighting professional- lighting auditor, I want you and others to go out and buy some now-
I use these in my own home, they are pretty good lamps.As far as calculators, there are many available.
The initial math, related to kW savings is just one consideration. Would you prefer not to have to
get on a ladder and change lights frequently? its another consideration.
The rationale to use them is there, the cost's have come down and the illuminance is very good -
with the sought after CCT ( color temperature) ie 2700 K or 2900K the CCT range of the ubiquitous
A-19 lamp-it is good for home use. As for the appropriateness of that CCT for a work environment - it's debatable.
If that would be in your best interest,( a whole subset topic) the CCT range and a desired selected
"set" CCT makes the Endura and other popular Philips LED luminiares - somewhat innapropriate
for the tasks at hand in a business office- (unless the office environment indicates a CCT range like
that - an example would be the interior of a funeral parlour that should be around 2900K)
- which would be inappropriate at an architect's drafting room, or a jewelry store.
If you want to send me a PM I would be happy to give a more detailed product summary -
I've been selling and promoting LEDs -- SSL for many years - I have more info and
acumen on the topic then anyone else in this forum ( most likely) -I could provide insights that
might make your choice an excellent one . read the next bit...
The one bit of news for folks switching to LED lighting next year-
I am pleasantly SHOCKED by the scope and breadth of advances
in solid state lighting over the last year- there have been so many
improvements , refinements & broad price drops market wide. It
is a good time to be starting the change over to LED lighting.
procrastinators, you did OK on your value proposition.Because...
With so many new advancements I can say ALL of you folks will be
using SSL at home + work within 100 weeks and the newer products
will have many improvements ie : lumens per a watt, Tuneable CCTs,
integrated IR sensors built in that detect room vacancy - built in
things like smoke detectors, air purifiers, speakers, addressability
for more functionality like seen in the Philips Hue- Ipad/ Iphone controlled
multi hued residential lighting....
do you want to be blown away by the WOW factor
then the advances in TFT, OLEDs and OLETs along with advances in
controls will dazzle you- REALLY, the future will have an array of sophisticated lighting - you folks
can barely imagine. So yeah folk jump on the bandwagon NOW. but keep high hopes
for even better products in '13 +14- you will definitely see the trend continue !
I like the LED light but would agree with Curt that the cost does not justify the difference at this time. However cost is not everything. There is the coolness factor and for many the LED is just plain hip. There is the health issue with mercury in the home as well.
I think either product is a huge upgrade from incandescent. I tried bringing some LED’s home at one point and the better half did not like the spectrum. This was some time ago and I know that much has changed since that costly mistake. Dennis suggests there will be more changes over the next 24 months. Since I believe he has probably forgotten more than I know about LED I look forward to seeing the new technology.
While I do believe that mercury is a problem it has been well documented that the amount of mercury released by a coal power plant for using more watts needed to burn an incandescent vs a CFL far outstrips the amount of mercury in a CFL. I do not ignore the problem but I am not swayed to not purchase the product nor do I shy from suggesting it to customers as an alternative to incandescent. I think we can all agree they should not be in the landfill and should be recycled.
I often see the figure of 13 watts but many CFLs run at less. The one next to my TV/Reading chair which illuminates just fine runs at less than 8 watts. While CFL were once and still are reviled I think the newer models aka the last 5 years or more have fixed the issue of flickering and color and are quite nice.
I think the biggest gain in LED is the spread has become much more pleasant. The lack of light diffusion I believe is one of the issues my wife did not like in the older LED that I have. The color is much better today as well as these lamps my wife disliked were very white.
I am unconvinced the health concern is of such great extent to trump the cost for me and believe the risks are low. At a cost of less than eight dollars for four bulbs at Home Depot CFL lighting is extremely cost effective.
I do not think the coolness factor can be overlooked as very few things in our industry are considered cool to those outside our industry besides PV solar and LED’s. Folks will pay for cool.
For those that despise CFL’s the choice is easy.
When one of our 50 or so CFLs dies, which seems to be about once per month, I drop it off at the dedicated box at Lowes or HoDepot
Curt, great idea! I always forget to stop at HD to dump the dead ones, gotta step it up! thanks, t
Thank you for your comments. I agree with most of them. Especially like your point about significant others and how the light looks. For HGTV watchers especially, this is huge! Meanwhile, back at the "test lab..." t